Public power, consumer groups launch grassroots effort to reform power markets
Read More 
Claiming that FERC "continues to ignore repeated calls from consumers and businesses to investigate" U.S. power markets, a diverse coalition of public power, industrials, public-interest organizations and consumer groups on June 12 launched a grassroots effort to reform the wholesale electricity markets created and operated by RTOs.
Dubbed the "Campaign for Fair Electric Rates," the coalition has also established a Web site encouraging electricity consumers to "tell ? your story" on "how increasingly high electric rates are impacting your life and that of your community"
Visitors to the Web site are asked to take a moment to share their stories and to "take a stand against unfair and unreasonable electricity rates." The coalition asks consumers to answer questions such as: "Have high electricity rates made it harder for you to pay your bills each month? Do you live on a limited income? Have you had to cut back on other expenses in your home? Are you a small business owner and have less money to expand or invest due to high electricity prices?"
Many of the coalition's members ? including the American Public Power Association and Electricity Consumers Resource Council ? have been complaining for some time that the sophisticated "Day 2" energy markets being run by various RTOs and ISOs are not providing the promised consumer benefits.
While FERC has taken certain steps aimed at improving these markets, APPA, ELCON and others have said these efforts have been far too limited, insisting that FERC instead launch a far more extensive inquiry into whether the RTOs' organized markets are producing "unjust and unreasonable" wholesale electricity prices. Thus far, FERC has refused those calls, and now APPA and ELCON have teamed up with 16 other groups to increase the pressure on the commission to make further reforms.
"We have now passed a decade in which the FERC has been trying and failing to make the electricity market work in the theoretical image of competition," said Mark Cooper, director of research for the Consumer Federation of America, a coalition member. "We are asking it to put the horse back in front of the cart, to put consumer protection where it belongs, at the center of its mission."
The coalition said its new campaign is aimed at educating consumers, businesses and the media "on the failures of restructured electricity markets." The coalition also encouraged consumers to contact their senators and representatives in the hopes that Congress will convince FERC to re-examine the changes made to the wholesale electricity markets over the last few years "and take all necessary steps to protect consumers against unjust and unreasonable rates."
"Congress needs to put pressure on FERC, either through oversight hearings or legislation, to fulfill its obligation of ensuring fair and reasonable rates for electric consumers," the coalition explains on its Web site.
The coalition further insisted that changes made to the wholesale electricity markets over the past few years have not produced competition, but instead have resulted in "exorbitant profits" for power generators, excessively high electricity rates, and insufficient investment in new power plants and transmission lines.
In particular, the coalition claimed that market rules allow generators "to charge high rates for electricity regardless of the actual costs, even when consumers have already largely paid for the generating plants." The coalition further complained that retail rates in states that have deregulated their retail market structures have increased by twice as much as rates in regulated states over the last 10 years.
The coalition said that, as a starting point, RTO-run markets should at least produce just and reasonable prices, be fair to all market participants, and share the benefits of fuel diversity and operational efficiencies equitably between consumers and suppliers. In addition, the coalition called for "improved and more timely transparency and accountability to consumers" and "a consumer-focused system that assures reliability and capacity growth to meet our future needs."
"It's time to restore fairness to the electricity markets and protect consumers," said Mark Crisson, APPA's CEO. "We're asking Congress and the FERC to address this growing crisis."
More information on the campaign, including a list of coalition members, fact sheets and other resources, can be viewed at the coalition's Web site: http://www.fairelectricrates.net.